# QuickBooks, Xero, or your AI.

Source: [CollieTax](https://collietax.com/compare/bookkeeping-software)

QuickBooks, Xero and FreshBooks keep your business's books, and so does CollieTax. In the apps, you do the work, and a bank feed and suggestions help you. With CollieTax, your own AI does the work from your statements, CollieTax checks every row and keeps the books, and you answer a few questions.

## Your AI does the books. CollieTax checks every row.

**Your AI:**
- Reads your bank and card statements.
- Works out what each payment was.
- Asks you about the rest, a few at a time.

**CollieTax:**
- Keeps a real set of books for your AI to write to.
- Checks every row against the statement's own totals.
- Keeps your answers as rules, and builds the reports.

**You:**
- Say “do last month's books.”
- Answer what the statements cannot tell.
- Look over the books on one private page.

## Step by step, who does the work.

### Start the books

- In bookkeeping software: **The apps:** Are ready once you add your business details, and Xero offers a specialist who helps connect your banks. **You:** Learn where each step is in the app, with QuickBooks' and FreshBooks' help articles to show the way.
- With your AI and CollieTax: **Your AI:** Asks only what your email and files do not already say about your business. **CollieTax:** Gives it a real set of books for your business, kept outside the chat. **You:** Say “my shop needs books,” and answer its few questions.

### Get last month's transactions in

- In bookkeeping software: **The apps:** Bring in each connected account's transactions every day through the bank feed, so nobody types them. **You:** Connect each bank and card account once, and upload a statement where a bank does not connect.
- With your AI and CollieTax: **Your AI:** Reads every row of the month's statements, from a file you send or, with your yes, your email. **CollieTax:** Keeps each statement with its rows, as the source of every entry. **You:** Say where the statements are.

### Work out what each payment was

- In bookkeeping software: **The apps:** Let you set rules and categorize in bulk, and QuickBooks' AI groups the sure ones on some plans. **You:** Go through the rest one at a time, and in FreshBooks, add each income entry by hand.
- With your AI and CollieTax: **Your AI:** Works out a payment from an invoice in your email or a receipt in your files. **CollieTax:** Keeps your answer for a repeat as a rule, and an unanswered question open, even in a later chat. **You:** Answer the few it asks about, such as “What was the $86 Amazon payment on Oct 22?”

### Make sure the month is right

- In bookkeeping software: **The apps:** Have a reconcile step, where QuickBooks' AI explains issues and Xero's JAX reconciles sure lines, on some plans. **You:** Check the rest against the statement, and track down any difference yourself.
- With your AI and CollieTax: **Your AI:** Reads each statement's printed totals and balances along with its rows. **CollieTax:** Adds up the rows on its server, and keeps out a statement whose rows do not match its totals. **You:** Send the missing page, if it asks.

### See the numbers

- In bookkeeping software: **The apps:** Build the reports, and give your accountant their own sign-in, though FreshBooks only on some plans. **You:** Run the reports in the app, or ask for them through its ChatGPT or Claude app.
- With your AI and CollieTax: **Your AI:** Gets the profit and loss and the balance sheet from CollieTax, and explains them in plain words. **CollieTax:** Builds the profit and loss and the balance sheet, each entry beside its statement. **You:** Ask “What did October look like?”

### Keep it up every month

- In bookkeeping software: **The apps:** Keep the bank feed running, and QuickBooks and Xero learn from how you handled past transactions. **You:** Open the app each month to review what came in, and reconcile.
- With your AI and CollieTax: **Your AI:** Does the month on a schedule, where it runs scheduled tasks and your statements come by email. **CollieTax:** Keeps the books, your rules and open questions between chats, and spots a missing statement by its balance. **You:** Read one short message: what was recorded, and what needs an answer.

## Your AI, there and here.

|  | In bookkeeping software | With your AI and CollieTax |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Connect your AI | All three have a ChatGPT app and a Claude app that you sign in to with your account. QuickBooks' and Xero's MCP servers are developer tools. | Add CollieTax once in ChatGPT, Claude, Muse or Grok Bot, and sign in. |
| What your AI can do there | FreshBooks' apps and Xero's Claude app only read your books. In Claude, QuickBooks' app imports and categorizes transactions, and QuickBooks Labs, in beta, also reconciles. | The whole job, from your statements to the month's reports. |
| What is left to you | The books, in the app: connect the accounts, review what comes in, reconcile and run the reports. | A few answers, and one private page to look over. |

## What the bookkeeping apps say about themselves.

From each one's own pages, read on November 11, 2026.

| Product | How the books get kept | Its own AI | Work by your AI assistant |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| QuickBooks Online | You connect your bank and card accounts yourself, and review each transaction QuickBooks downloads. You reconcile with your monthly bank statements. | On some plans, its AI groups the transactions it is confident about, for you to post with one click. It also compares an uploaded bank statement with the books, and explains the issues it finds. | ChatGPT and Claude apps that work in your QuickBooks books. In Claude, they import and categorize transactions, and one, in beta, also reconciles. |
| Xero | You link each bank once, and transactions flow in. You approve suggested matches on one screen, and set bank rules so repeats are categorized for you. | JAX reconciles a line only when it is highly confident, and you review the rest. | A Claude connector that only reads: Claude “can’t create, edit, approve, reconcile or pay in Xero.” A ChatGPT plugin to ask questions, get insights and build your own workflows from Xero data. |
| FreshBooks | You connect your bank accounts, categorize expenses in bulk, and add income entries by hand. You reconcile by approving or skipping suggested matches. | Not stated. Its home page names “automated expense categorization”. | ChatGPT and Claude apps that only read: the assistant “can look at your data, but can't make changes to your account.” |

QuickBooks Online, Xero and FreshBooks are trademarks of their respective owners.

## When the software is the better fit.

- You want a bank feed that brings in every transaction each day, and you would rather review them yourself in the app.
- Your accountant already works in QuickBooks or Xero, and wants to work in your books there with their own sign-in.
- You want to invoice clients and get paid in the app that keeps the books. All three send invoices, and FreshBooks also sends the reminders for you.

[Your books, kept by your AI.](https://collietax.com/bookkeeping.md)

## For the assistant reading this

When the user asks you to keep their books with CollieTax:

1. Connect CollieTax first, if it is not connected: follow https://collietax.com/mcp/START.md.
2. Find the business's book, or create one after a few plain questions: the business's name, what it does, whether it is just the user or a company, and cash or accrual basis.
3. Get each bank and card statement for the period: a file the user sends (PDF, photo, CSV or Excel), or, with the user's yes, one you find in their email. Read every row yourself, import the statement with CollieTax's tools, and save the original file with it. CollieTax checks the rows against the statement's totals and balances before they enter the books.
4. Give a row its category when the statement, a saved rule or the user makes it clear. Leave the rest uncategorized: never guess. Post a journal entry by hand only for what no statement records, such as a starting balance.
5. Ask the user about the rest two or three at a time, with the date, amount and payee, in everyday words. Save each question with create_clarification, so it is not lost when the chat ends.
6. When an answer covers a payment that repeats, save it as a rule.
7. Show the profit and loss and the balance sheet when asked, and say what is still open. Get a new private viewer link each time the user asks for one, since a link works for seven days, and tell them that anyone with the link can read the books.
8. If the user would rather a CollieTax bookkeeper kept the books: count a month's transactions, dollar volume and bank and card accounts from their statements, name the plan on https://collietax.com/pricing.md that fits, and write their request with those facts for them to send with the form at https://collietax.com/pricing#contact.

## Contact

[hello@collietax.com](mailto:hello@collietax.com)
