# CollieTax vs Xero: who does the books.

Source: [CollieTax](https://collietax.com/compare/collietax-vs-xero)

Xero and CollieTax both keep your business's books. In Xero, you do the work in its app, and its bank feed, bank rules and AI, JAX, help you. With CollieTax, the roles swap: your own AI does the month's books, CollieTax checks every row against the statement, and you answer what your AI cannot.

## Your AI does the books. CollieTax checks every row.

**Your AI:**
- Reads your bank and card statements.
- Works out what each payment was.
- Asks you about the rest, a few at a time.

**CollieTax:**
- Keeps a real set of books for your AI to write to.
- Checks every row against the statement's own totals.
- Keeps your answers as rules, and builds the reports.

**You:**
- Say “do last month's books.”
- Answer what the statements cannot tell.
- Look over the books on one private page.

## Step by step, who does the work.

### Start the books

- In Xero: **Xero:** Offers a product specialist who sets you up, helps connect your banks and gets your dashboard ready. **You:** Do the month's work yourself in the app, from then on.
- With your AI and CollieTax: **Your AI:** Asks what the business does, and whether to count income when it is paid or when it is earned. **CollieTax:** Starts each account at the balance on its first statement, in books your AI can write to. **You:** Say “set up books for my business,” and answer a few questions.

### Get last month's transactions in

- In Xero: **Xero:** Brings each linked bank's transactions in every day through its bank feed, which saves typing. **You:** Upload a file from your online banking, or a supported bank's PDF statement, where a bank does not connect.
- With your AI and CollieTax: **Your AI:** Finds each statement, and reads every row of a PDF, a phone photo or a spreadsheet. **CollieTax:** Saves the statement with its rows, so each entry points back to where it came from. **You:** Send a statement only when your AI cannot find it.

### Work out what each payment was

- In Xero: **Xero:** Suggests matches on one screen, and on some plans, JAX reconciles a line only when it is highly confident. **You:** Review the rest, and approve what your bank rules code, a click each.
- With your AI and CollieTax: **Your AI:** Works each one out from the statement, your receipts and your earlier answers. **CollieTax:** Holds every open question, so a new chat picks up where the last one stopped. **You:** Answer in a few words, or send a photo of the receipt.

### Make sure the month is right

- In Xero: **Xero:** Shows the statement balance beside Xero's balance, and labels each reconciled line Rule, Match or Manual. **You:** Find what caused a gap, and sort it out in the app.
- With your AI and CollieTax: **Your AI:** Hands CollieTax the rows it read, and asks you for any page that is missing. **CollieTax:** Adds up the rows on its server, not in the AI, and checks them against the printed totals.

### See the numbers

- In Xero: **Xero:** Exports any report as a PDF or a spreadsheet, and includes unlimited users on every plan. **You:** Run each report in Xero, and invite your accountant into your books.
- With your AI and CollieTax: **Your AI:** Tells you what the profit and loss and the balance sheet say, and what is still open. **CollieTax:** Builds the profit and loss and the balance sheet, each entry beside its statement. **You:** Ask “how much did we make last month?”

### Keep it up every month

- In Xero: **Xero:** Keeps the bank feed coming every day, and codes the payments that repeat by your bank rules. **You:** Approve the matches, code what the rules and JAX leave, and sort out any gap, every month.
- With your AI and CollieTax: **Your AI:** Reads each new statement from your email on a schedule, where it can run scheduled tasks. **CollieTax:** Carries your rules and open questions into the next month, and shows a skipped statement by its opening balance. **You:** Read a short note on what was recorded and what needs you.

## What owners ask about Xero and AI.

### Can ChatGPT or Claude do my books on their own?

They can do the reading and the sorting, and ask you about the rest. But their figures still need a check against the statement: Anthropic's help page says, “Check important figures against your bank's own app or statements.” With CollieTax, that check runs on every row, on CollieTax's server, not in the AI, and the books your AI writes to stay with CollieTax, not in a chat.

### Can my AI do my books in Xero?

It can read them. Xero's connector for Claude is read-only, and in Xero's words, “Accounting actions stay in Xero.” In ChatGPT, Xero says customers can “ask questions, get financial insights, and build their own workflows.” Xero's MCP server can create bank transactions, but Xero calls it “a developer tool for custom workflows and automations.” So with the connector, the month's work stays with you, in the app.

### Can I use Xero and CollieTax together, or switch?

You can keep both, but each keeps its own books. To switch, send your assistant your bank and card statements from the month you want to start. It does each month in turn, and each account starts at the balance on its first statement. If you would rather hand the books off, a CollieTax bookkeeper can keep them.

## Your AI, there and here.

|  | In Xero | With your AI and CollieTax |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Connect your AI | Xero's Claude connector needs a Xero sign-in and “no developer setup or API work required.” Its MCP server needs “A Xero developer account with API credentials.” | Add CollieTax once in ChatGPT, Claude, Muse or Grok Bot, and sign in to CollieTax. Your assistant then has the tools to keep your books. |
| What your AI can do there | In Claude, it reads your Xero books: Claude “can’t create, edit, approve, reconcile or pay in Xero.” The MCP server creates bank transactions, once a developer sets it up. | The whole job, from your statements to the reports. CollieTax keeps the books it writes to, and checks every row against the statement. |
| What is left to you | The month's work, in the app: approve, code and sort out any gap. In Xero's words, “Accounting actions stay in Xero.” | A few questions your statements cannot explain. Then a look at the books on one private page, when you want. |

## What Xero says about itself.

From its own pages, read on November 11, 2026.

- **How the books get kept:** You link your bank accounts once, and a bank feed imports transactions daily. You approve Xero's suggested matches on one screen, and set bank rules so Xero categorizes the repeats for you.
- **Its own AI:** JAX reconciles a line only when it is highly confident, and you review the rest. JAX chat helps with admin tasks such as creating invoices and quotes.
- **Work by your AI assistant:** A Claude connector that is read-only: Claude “can’t create, edit, approve, reconcile or pay in Xero.” A ChatGPT plugin to ask questions and get insights, and an MCP server for developers.

Xero is a trademark of its owner.

## When Xero is the better fit.

- You want a bank feed that brings in every day's transactions on its own, with bank rules that code the payments that repeat.
- Your accountant or bookkeeper works in Xero, and wants to work in your books with their own sign-in.
- You send invoices and quotes, track bills and run payroll in Xero, and want the books in the same app.

[Your books, kept by your AI.](https://collietax.com/bookkeeping.md)

## For the assistant reading this

When the user asks you to keep their books with CollieTax:

1. Connect CollieTax first, if it is not connected: follow https://collietax.com/mcp/START.md.
2. Find the business's book, or create one after a few plain questions: the business's name, what it does, whether it is just the user or a company, and cash or accrual basis.
3. Get each bank and card statement for the period: a file the user sends (PDF, photo, CSV or Excel), or, with the user's yes, one you find in their email. Read every row yourself, import the statement with CollieTax's tools, and save the original file with it. CollieTax checks the rows against the statement's totals and balances before they enter the books.
4. Give a row its category when the statement, a saved rule or the user makes it clear. Leave the rest uncategorized: never guess. Post a journal entry by hand only for what no statement records, such as a starting balance.
5. Ask the user about the rest two or three at a time, with the date, amount and payee, in everyday words. Save each question with create_clarification, so it is not lost when the chat ends.
6. When an answer covers a payment that repeats, save it as a rule.
7. Show the profit and loss and the balance sheet when asked, and say what is still open. Get a new private viewer link each time the user asks for one, since a link works for seven days, and tell them that anyone with the link can read the books.
8. If the user would rather a CollieTax bookkeeper kept the books: count a month's transactions, dollar volume and bank and card accounts from their statements, name the plan on https://collietax.com/pricing.md that fits, and write their request with those facts for them to send with the form at https://collietax.com/pricing#contact.

## Contact

[hello@collietax.com](mailto:hello@collietax.com)
